A ban on outside spending identical to the one Scott Brown and Elizabeth Warren agreed to earlier this year could be coming to the 6th Congressional District race.
U.S. Rep. Jon Tierney yesterday challenged his Republican opponent, Richard Tisei, to sign a “People’s Pledge” to discourage outside interest groups from influencing their rough-and-tumble campaign.
The pledge mirrors a pact signed by Brown and Warren in January requiring the candidates to contribute money to a charity if outside groups advertise on their behalf.
Tierney’s proposal comes one month after Tisei proposed limiting the amount of donations that political-action committees, or PACs, can make in their race. Tierney refused and accused Tisei of trying to distract voters from important issues.
Now, Tierney wants the two campaigns to sign a pledge to prevent outside groups from airing independent television, radio or Internet ads supporting or attacking either candidate. If they do, the candidate who benefited from the ad has to pay 50 percent of the ad’s cost to a charity chosen by their opponent.
“Since we are running in the same state as these Senate candidates, will confront many of the same issues, and will be subject to the same interest by outside third party groups, I see no reason why we would not enter into the exact same agreement, unless one of our campaigns decided that we actually want these outside groups running attack ads in this state,” said Tierney, of Salem.
Just hours after Tierney released his proposal, Tisei shot back with a fiery response, accusing his Democratic rival of funding his campaign through PAC money from Washington. Tisei said if Tierney is serious about curbing the influence of outside money in their race, he should agree to one of his four proposals.
“After I’ve out raised him two quarters in a row — the vast majority of my fundraising coming from individual donors, not PACs — he’s suddenly finding religion,” said Tisei. “John Tierney is a PAC addict. He has been for years. Is he finally admitting that he has a problem?”
Arguing that it is better to receive as much financial support from within the district as possible, in March Tisei had asked Tierney to agree to one of four scenarios: End all PAC contributions; end all PAC contributions from outside of Massachusetts; limit PAC contributions to 20 percent of all contributions; or limit all donations to those coming from Massachusetts.
Tisei, a former state senator from Wakefield, raised $354,467 in the first quarter of 2012 compared to Tierney’s $325,125 during the same period. Tierney has $795,184 cash on hand, however, compared to $454,526 for Tisei. Tierney has raised 43 percent of his money this election cycle from PACs, compared to just 5 percent for Tisei. The People’s Pledge does not cover PACs, focusing instead on groups that place ads independent of the campaigns.
While PAC contributions to candidates are limited to $5,000 and must be publicly disclosed, super PACs must do any political spending independently of the campaigns. Unlike traditional PACs, super PACs can raise unlimited money from corporations, unions and individuals.
Tierney’s district, which now includes Billerica and Tewksbury, as well as parts of Andover, is seen by state GOP leaders as ripe for the picking in this year’s elections.
Since Brown and Warren signed the “People’s Pledge,” outside groups that had been spending millions of dollars on attack ads have by-and-large stayed away from the high-stakes U.S. Senate race.
– Chris Camire